The chilling effect

How the Web makes creating software vulnerabilities easier, disclosing them more difficult and discovering them possibly illegal.

A wake-up call for websites

Around breakfast one day late last August, RSnake started a thread on his discussion board,, a site frequented by hackers and researchers looking for interesting new exploits and trends in Web vulnerabilities. RSnake's first post was titled "So it begins." All that followed were two links, and, and a short note: "These have been out there for a while but are still unfixed." Clicking on the links exploited XSS vulnerabilities with a reasonably harmless, proof-of-concept script. RSnake had disclosed vulnerabilities.

He did this because he felt the research community and, more to the point, the public at large, neither understood nor respected the seriousness and prevalence of XSS. It was time, he says, to do some guerilla vulnerability disclosure. "I want them to understand this isn't Joe Shmoe finding a little hole and building a phishing site," RSnake says. "This is one of the pieces of the puzzle that could be used as a nasty tool."

If that first post didn't serve as a wake-up call, what followed it should. Hundreds of XSS vulnerabilities were disclosed by the regular klatch of hackers at the site. Most exploited well-known, highly trafficked sites. Usually the posts included a link that included a proof-of-concept exploit. An XSS hole in, for example, simply delivered a pop-up dialog box with an exclamation mark in the box. By early October, anonymous lurkers were contributing long lists of XSS-vulnerable sites. In one set of these, exploit links connected to a defaced page with Sylvester Stallone's picture on it and the message "This page has been hacked! You got Stallown3d!1" The sites this hacker contributed included the websites of USA Today, The New York Times, The Boston Globe, ABC, CBS, Warner Bros., Petco, Nike, and Linens 'n Things. "What can I say?" RSnake wrote. "We have some kick-ass lurkers here."

Some of the XSS holes were closed up shortly after appearing on the site. Others remain vulnerable. At least one person tried to get the discussion board shut down, RSnake says, and a couple of others "didn't react in a way that I thought was responsible." Contacts from a few of the victim sites -- Google and Mozilla, among others -- called to tell RSnake they'd fixed the problem and "to say thanks through gritted teeth." Most haven't contacted him, and he suspects most know about neither the discussion thread nor their XSS vulnerabilities.

By early November last year, the number of vulnerable sites posted reached 1,000, many discovered by RSnake himself. His signature on his posts reads "RSnake - Gotta love it." It connotes an aloofness that permeates the discussion thread, as if finding XSS vulnerabilities were too easy. It's fun but hardly professionally interesting, like Tom Brady playing flag football.

Clearly, this is not responsible disclosure by the standards shrink-wrapped software has come to be judged, but RSnake doesn't think responsible disclosure, even if it were somehow developed for Web vulnerabilities (and we've already seen how hard that will be, technically), can work. For one, he says, he'd be spending all day filling out vulnerability reports. But more to the point, "If I went out of my way to tell them they're vulnerable, they may or may not fix it, and, most importantly, the public doesn't get that this is a big problem."

Join the newsletter!


Sign up to gain exclusive access to email subscriptions, event invitations, competitions, giveaways, and much more.

Membership is free, and your security and privacy remain protected. View our privacy policy before signing up.

Error: Please check your email address.
Follow our new CSO Australia LinkedIn
Follow our new social and we'll keep you in the loop for exclusive events and all things security!
Have an opinion on security? Want to have your articles published on CSO? Please contact CSO Content Manager for our guidelines.

More about ABC NetworksACTAltavistaCarnegie Mellon University AustraliaCBS CorporationCERT AustraliaCiscoCreativeFBIGatewayGoogleHISIBM AustraliaIETFInternet Engineering Task ForceISS GroupMcAfee AustraliaMellonMessengerMicrosoftMozillaNetcraftNikePayPalPetcoPromiseSecure ComputingSpeedUSCVIAWarner Bros

Show Comments

Featured Whitepapers

Editor's Recommendations

Brand Page

Stories by Scott Berinato

Latest Videos

More videos

Blog Posts